What do I do if my claim is turned down?
Firstly don’t despair. Many, many claims for DLA are turned down or the allowance is reduced on re-application.
Reasons may include the following.
-
Not enough information was included in the original claim.
-
The wrong person was asked to complete the medical parts of the form.
-
The wrong person was asked to complete the medical parts of the form.
-
The wrong person read the form when it reached the DWP.
-
The care needs of the child have changed and the allowance has been altered.
-
No help was given when the forms were completed.
-
Someone without enough specialist knowledge helped with the application.
Refusal of the allowance
If the DWP (Department for Work and Pensions) come back with a refusal for the allowance they will give reasons for the refusal.
If you dispute the comments and the decision then your initial response is to ask for the application to be reconsidered or revised. This is known as mandatory reconsideration. You need to write within one month of the date of the decision letter explaining your reasons and asking for a revision to the decision. You cannot appeal without having first asked for a mandatory reconsideration.
The allowance may be awarded following a reconsideration or revision; if it is not and you do not agree with the reasons for refusal you have a right to formally appeal the decision.
Appeal process
A majority of DLA applications are being refused, the DWP has been tasked with reducing positive claims and it seems that they are pruning out applicants by refusing allowances at first application.
LHM is likely to suggest that a family seek to appeal a refusal for either the care or mobility section of the grant.
Most babies would be entitled to higher rate care component at least for the first year especially if feeding and heart failure are an issue.
Older children should receive a care and mobility component but rarely top rate for either. There is usually little, if any, overnight care and supported mobility from carers.
Young adults should receive lower or middle care component and higher mobility allowance. Achieving independent adulthood is almost impossible without some care support e.g. cooking meals for a tired adult and mobility support for independence.
The appeal process will be enclosed with the mandatory reconsideration notices (sometimes called a ‘written statement of reasons’). You must work to the specified timescales. There is a form to complete and submit within a month of the decision which asks for your reasons for asking for an appeal. You need to say that you will submit evidence and support to qualify your claim. The ‘written statement of reasons’ will help you prepare your appeal.
This is when LHM can step in with further support by way of a personal letter to support the appeal with information about the child’s disability needs.
It is essential that the LHM team have a copy of the initial application so that they can accurately word the appeal letter. If you don’t have a copy of the submission, you should ask for one when you appeal and then forward a copy to the LHM team.
You should be given the choice between an ‘oral hearing’ (face-to-face) and a ‘paper hearing’. Think about which one you would prefer. If you choose a ‘paper hearing’, this will give you the chance to send as much extra information as possible, and you could still choose an ‘oral hearing’ later if the ‘paper hearing’ is unsuccessful.
An ‘oral hearing’ is a meeting where a panel will discuss your case; the panel is usually a lawyer, a doctor and someone experienced in the needs of disabled people. You will need to submit further written evidence before the meeting but you will also be invited to the meeting to discuss your appeal, and will have the opportunity to explain your child’s situation.
Although it may seem more stressful appearing in front of the panel it does allow you an opportunity to answer the panel’s questions. More successful claims come from face-to-face appeals (oral hearings) than written ones.
If this appeal is refused you can ask for the case to be considered by the Upper Tribunal. This is a panel of experts and lawyers who will conduct a hearing into the case. You will have to attend a meeting where the case is discussed and can take a local expert to support you e.g. someone from Citizens Advice or someone from the hospital.
LHM offers support over the phone in preparation for a Tribunal or appeal but we are unable to offer support at the Tribunal itself. We can help you to think about who might be useful to write to for additional evidence, and also which areas you should stress in your appeal.